Reusable grocery bags. Photo by Malcolm Denmark
By: Sharon Aron Baron
It’s so hard to resist those small plastic bags. Store clerks mindlessly fill them with one or two items, and they can’t help but double or triple bag them as they have become so flimsy. Take a look at people walking out of the grocery store; you will see nothing but a shopping cart full of 10-20 of these.
Plastic bags hold minimal groceries.
Did you know that 90 percent of the plastic bags in the US are not even recycled? Recycled bags can go on to make lumber, trashcan liners, or other plastic bags. Publix has plastic recycling containers in front where these can be deposited. However, the one thing people can do now is stopping the use of these bags. People need to get into the habit of using reusable grocery bags. These bags can hold so much more than plastic and can be re-used for many years.
There are times when I forgo getting any bag at a store. I tell store clerks to save the bag as I’ll carry the items out with me. Yesterday at Barnes and Noble, a clerk put a magazine and a small book inside a bag. I told him to save the bag as I would carry them out. I can’t imagine someone not being able to carry the books they buy out of a store. Putting purchases in plastic bags has become so automated for clerks, and customers must get proactive and say no to more plastic bags.
Using plastic bags to pick up messes left by their dog is not the best way to reuse these bags. Unfortunately, it takes over 1,000 years for that plastic bag to break down in the landfill. There are many biodegradable dog bags at pet stores now, and some types are even compostable. You can even get a container that attaches to your dog’s leash, so you’ll never leave home without one.
Many cities have banned plastic bags or have imposed a fee on them. Here is a list of cities banning or addressing the plastic bag issue as of 2011:
Cities that have banned plastic bags
San Francisco
Malibu
Palo Alto
Fairfax – voluntary removal of bags
San Jose
Long beach
Calabasas Feb. 3, 2011
Places in U.S. considering ban
Portland
Maui Kauai
Brownsville TX
American Samoa
Boston
Phoenix
Baltimore
Arcata CA
Sunnyvale CA
Jersey City NJ
Wilton CT
Dubuque IA
Locations around the world with a plastic bag ban
Italy
Mexico City
Thompson City, Canada
Wood Buffalo, Alberta, Canada (All single-use bags)
Thailand
Delhi, India
Mumbai, India
Karwar, India
Tirumala, India
Vasco, India
Rangoon, Burma
Bangladesh (bags have been banned since 2002)
Rwanda
Sydney’s Oyster Bay in Australia (along with twelve other towns in Australia)
Israel
Places around the world considering the ban
France
London
Places Discouraging plastic bag use
Washington DC (5 cent tax)
Madison, Wis. ( mandatory plastic bag recycling law)
Many European countries have a tax on the bag
China does not give out free bags
The largest opposition to the ban of plastic bags comes from the petroleum and plastics industries, and of course, consumers who don’t want to change their habits.
Florida could join the list of cities and countries with enough plastic bags filling up our landfills. There seemed to be some action taken by the Crist administration when they required the Department of Environmental Protection to perform an analysis and submit a report to the legislature regarding plastic bags. Until such time that the Legislature adopts the recommendations of DEP, no local or state government may enact any regulation or tax on the use of such retail bags. This is why no city or county in Florida can do what individual towns have done in California.
This does not prevent individual stores from banning plastic bags as Whole Foods did in April of 2008. Whole Foods customers have the choice of paper or reusable bags. When customers bring in their bags, Whole Foods will credit them $.05 for each one used. Same with Target. Although they have not banned plastic bags, they give customers with reusable bags the same credit, but pay attention, as many store clerks forget to credit customers for doing this.
According to Florida Environmental Public Information Officer Kristin Lock, “During the 2010 legislative session, the Florida legislature did not enact any legislation regarding the regulation of retail bags. The legislature also did not repeal section 403.7033, Florida Statutes, which prohibits any local government, local governmental agency, or state government agency from enacting any rule, regulation, or ordinance regarding use, disposition, sale, prohibition, restriction, or tax of such auxiliary containers, wrappings, or disposable plastic bags.”
Until our state enacts changes for plastic bags, it is up to corporations such as Walmart, Publix, and other major retailers to do their part to encourage reusable bags or ban plastic bags altogether. Until then, residents must do their part to make a difference in the amount of bags they will consume.
Author Profile
- Editor of Talk Media and writer for Coral Springs Talk. CST was created in 2012 to provide News, Views, and Entertainment for the residents of Coral Springs and the rest of South Florida.
Related
EventsApril 24, 2024Coral Springs Holds Next Family Fun Night at the Panthers Ice Den
EventsApril 23, 2024Area High Schools Nominated for Cappie Theater Awards
EventsApril 23, 2024Coral Springs Holds its 2024 EarthFest Plant Giveaway
Crime & SafetyApril 23, 2024Protect Your Identity at Coral Springs’ Free Shredathon on May 4
3 comments
It’s sad that good motivations could bring bad rules regarding plastic bags to Dubuque or to Coral Springs.
A measure designed to discourage merchants from providing plastic bags is being considered by the City Council there. If it is enacted and plastic bag use is reduced, the environmental consequences will be opposite of what is intended.
That’s because the most frequent “reusable” bags, made of non-woven polypropylene, have a greater carbon footprint than plastic due to fossil fuel usage and poor durability. Their failed remnants present disposal problems that are perhaps worse than plastic’s. The social consequences of their use also are severe because virtually all are made in Chinese sweatshops.
Studies indicate that, unlike a few years ago, most plastic bags are reused at least once or are recycled. One ingenious British analysis shows that you would need to use most “reusable” bags dozens of times to achieve better eco-friendly results than with a plastic bag that is reused only one time.
Surprisingly, the more expensive and durable cotton reusable grocery bags are even less earth-friendly because of the huge quantity of fossil fuels required in growing, processing and manufacturing.
There are good alternatives to these poor reusable bags, but all are expensive. Merchants pushing the cheap reusables gain an undeserved reputation for being green-oriented. Their customers are lured into believing that they are trendy by being seen acting “green.” It’s a massive fraud from which we all suffer due to environmental damage.
The Dubuque Council will serve its city best by encouraging wise use of plastic or the more expensive reusables made from organic cotton, hemp, jute or kudzu. An Iowa-based social enterprise I am sponsoring offers the Nature Bag, Earth’s Greenest Bag, which is crafted in homes without agriculture or manufacturing, is durable, elastic, minimalistic and lightweight. In the unlikely event the Khmu’s kudzu bag ever becomes reusable, burying it will help your garden grow!
Paper is a renewable resource; can be reused, recycled, or composted; is biodegradable; holds 10x what a plastic bag can hold meaning less are used; trees grown are good for the Earth providing oxygen and cleaning the air (yes a field may need to be cut down to grow trees that are used for paper, but a field is also cut down to build a plastic factory); when trees are cut down for paper more tress are planted in their place; etc.
Paper bags aren’t the perfect solution but they are a heck of a lot better than plastic and possibly even the cheap reusable bags you mention.
When I go to Walmart I dread all the bags, when I get to my car I can rebag them into 2 bags from 6 bags. I like going to Aldi’s I use my cloth bags, and I also like to do my own bagging.
I agree Walmart employees mindlessly put 2 things in one bag and then use another, I always tell them I do not want to many bags, but they just ignore me.